New Zealand Ice Cream Manufacturers' Assn - home The New Zealand Ice Cream Awards Awards 2007
Awards 2006
Awards 2005
Awards 2004
Awards 2003
Awards 2002
Awards 2001
Awards 2000  
 
New Zealand Ice Cream Manufacturers' Assn - home
About the New Zealand Ice Cream Manufacturers' Assn
Directory of NZ Ice Cream Manufacturers' Assn members
Join the New Zealand Ice Cream Manufacturers' Assn - home
About the New Zealand ice cream industry
The New Zealand Ice Cream Awards
Ice Cream Code of Practice - Password required
Ice cream on the Web
Contact the NZICMA
What makes New Zealand ice cream so good?

NZ Ice Cream Awards 2008
The 12th NEW ZEALAND ICE CREAM AWARDS were announced last night (Thursday, 29th of May) at the NZICMA Annual Conference and Awards dinner, held in Christchurch.

The most popular ice cream flavour in New Zealand, Standard Vanilla has won the Supreme Award of The 2008 New Zealand Ice Cream Awards. Invercargill-based ice cream manufacturers Deep South have fought off challenges from all the exotic Premium ice cream flavours, proving that vanilla is the heart of good ice cream.

The Supreme Award is given to the ice cream with the highest score across all Categories, and this year the Award went to the winner of the Standard Vanilla Ice Cream Category with a score of 99 points:

The Supreme Award for 2008 went to Deep South 2007 Ltd for their
Standard Vanilla Ice Cream

Not only did Deep South win the Supreme Award, but they also won Best in Category for their Standard Chocolate and Hokey Pokey ice creams.

THE FULL LIST OF AWARDS is here.

A record 206 entries greeted the judges during the days of 7 – 9th May when the annual Ice Cream Awards were judged at the Massey University campus, Food Technology Department in Albany, Auckland. Food technology students acted as stewards enabling the judges to focus on getting through the large number of entries. The judges were Mrs Kay McMath, Ms Joanna Boese and Ms Susan Crowhen of Auckland and Mr Craig Davis from Sydney.

International judging guidelines were followed with each ice cream being awarded the maximum possible marks of 100 and from this points were deducted for various imperfections in each of 4 areas:

Appearance defects
Body and texture
Flavour defects
Melting defects.

It was a mammoth task to choose not only the awards for each category (now 12 in total including packaging), but to find an overall winner.

The areas of growth this year were in the new class of Premium vanilla, Premium ice cream (up by 16%) and Gelatos and Sorbets (up by 10%)

With increasing costs of raw materials and the squeeze exerted by the retail giants – the challenge is for ice cream manufacturers to continue to produce a creamy flavour and texture such as is known and expected by the New Zealand consumer. While the temptation is to reduce costs at the expense of quality – manufacturers who were able to maintain that full bodied flavour and texture of the dairy ingredients really won on the day.

The first category judged (Standard vanilla ice cream) is always a good indicator of the quality to come. If manufacturers can meet the challenge of making a product with good mouthfeel and flavour in this category, without the luxury of higher fat and indulgent flavours to give that premium experience – they truly know and understand what constitutes ice cream quality.

Again this year, for the sixth consecutive time, the award for the Best Standard Vanilla Ice cream went to Deep South, which also won the Supreme Award.

The Open Creative Category attracted several new entrants with some very novel ideas. The judges were exposed to peanut butter ice cream, bacon and egg ice cream and Mexican ice cream (a mix of chilli and corn chips).

Children aged 8 – 12 years from Dairy Flat Primary School, accompanied by just as enthusiastic principal and parents, came along to judge the Kids Choice category. The children were certainly not afraid of using extremes of the scale from “yum” to “yuk” to sort out the winners among 14 entries targeted at them. For their efforts – the sponsors of this category, Salkat New Zealand Ltd presented the children with their own “Ice Cream Judge 2008” apparel. Kid's Choice category was won by Fonterra Brands (Tip Top) Goody Goody Gum Drops.

The Premium Category is where the higher milk fat content (>12%) allows manufacturers to indulge their fantasies in a wide range of flavours. Favourites such as Hokey Pokey went head to head with new flavours of Blue Cheese and Pear, and Pecan and Pumpkin. The winner of this category, Killinchy Gold Cookies & Cream, managed to combine the flavours of both cookies and cream in an all natural vanilla ice cream with Oreo cookies.

The challenges of making a low fat product which has the mouthfeel and flavour release of a full fat version is a test of not only formulations, but also process control. The closest entry to match the perception of a full cream product – without the kilojoules, was an all-natural 97% fat free frozen yoghurt made with wild berry ripple manufactured by New Zealand Natural Pty Ltd.

The Gelato/Gelati/Sorbet category attracted a record 44 entries. Fruit flavours competed with chocolate and various coffee styles with the addition of nuts, honey and alcohol for more indulgence. The category continues to grow with consumers enjoying the superior quality of the flavour varieties possible in these formulations. The category was won by Kapiti Tamarillo Sorbet.

The Packaging categories were redefined this year to include only new packaging which had been introduced during the past 12 months, plus a category for Innovative Packaging. Judging was performed by Tom Robertson, Senior Lecturer in Packaging at Massey University. The Innovative category was won by Fonterra Brands (Tip Top) Ltd for their Big Thumb Stick and the new packaging category was won by New Zealand Natural Pty Ltd.

The New Zealand Ice Cream Manufacturers’ Association enjoys its 81st year and is testimony to the strength of the industry to survive increasing competition from imported products. Being a nation of dairy consumers - New Zealanders love their own unique style of ice cream. Healthy indulgence without the guilt, is the theme of this year’s Conference and remains the challenge for the supplier companies and manufacturers. The Ice Cream Awards will continue to promote creativity, excellence and innovation in the industry.

THE FULL LIST OF AWARDS is here.

Any further information is available from:

Mrs Jenny de Lisle, NZICMA Secretary - Office: 04 385 1410
Mrs Kay McMath, Chief Judge - Mobile: 021 88 1643

The categories and sponsors of the 2008 New Zealand Ice Cream Awards were:

GOLD SPONSORSHIP
Chelsea Sugar
Danisco New Zealand Ltd

SILVER SPONSORSHIP
Formula Foods Corporation Ltd
Huhtamaki Henderson Ltd
Salkat New Zealand Ltd
Waldrons Confectionery

AWARDS SPONSORSHIP
Allberry House Ltd
Fonterra (NZ) Ltd
Invita NZ Ltd
Kerry New Zealand ‘Simply’ Sugars
RD2 International Ltd
Sensient Technologies Corporation

Category - Sponsored by
1(a) Standard Vanilla Ice Cream - Invita NZ Ltd
1(b) Premium Vanilla Ice Cream - Formula Foods Corporation Ltd
2 Standard Chocolate Ice Cream - Sensient Technologies Corporation
3 Standard Ice Cream with Additions - Waldrons Confectionery
4 Premium Ice Cream - Danisco New Zealand Ltd
5 Open Creative - Chelsea Sugar
6 Kids Choice - Salkat New Zealand Ltd
7 Export Ice Cream - Fonterra (NZ) Ltd
8 Gelato and Sorbet - RD2 International Ltd
9 Low Fat - Allberry House Ltd
10(a) New Packaging (introduced in prev. 12 months) - Huhtamaki Henderson Ltd
10(b) ‘Innovation in Packaging and Distribution’ - Kerry New Zealand ‘Simply Sugars’


Back to top

NZ Ice Cream Awards 2007
The eleventh New Zealand Ice Cream Awards were announced at the annual NZICMA Conference in ROTORUA on Thursday, 31st of May 2007.

The grass is not always green !! This has been proven by Kapiti Fine Foods as their “Lemon Grass and Ginger Ice Cream” has won the Supreme Award of the 2007 New Zealand Ice Cream Awards.

The Supreme Award is given to the ice cream with the highest score across all categories. This year the award went to the winner of the Export Category with a score of 99.25 points for their ice cream destined for Asia.

The Supreme Award for 2007 went to Kapiti Fine Foods Ltd for their
Lemon Grass and Ginger Ice Cream

2007 Supreme Award winners
Winners of the Supreme Award: The team from Kapiti Fine Foods (L-R) John Allen, Stefan Thomson, Leanne Court, Gina Klarwill and Tim Beck

The FULL LIST OF 2007 AWARDS is here.
PHOTOS from the 2007 Awards judging and presentations are here.

JUDGING
International judging guidelines were followed with each ice cream being awarded the maximum possible marks of 100, from which points were deducted for various imperfections in each of 4 areas:

Appearance defects
Body and texture
Flavour defects
Melting defects

Entries were in 9 categories with Category 5 (Open Creative) being split into Ice Cream (Category 5a) and Gelato/Sorbets (Category 5b). This made the task of the judges very much easier in comparing like samples with like.

CATEGORY RESULTS
The overall Award in the Open Creative Category went to Rush Munro’s for their Rose Petal ice cream (complete with inclusions of chocolate covered petals), while Valentino’s, a small Auckland Gelati owner operator, was the highest scoring entry in the Gelato/Sorbet class for their Blackberry Pie (authentic even down to the pastry flavour !). Entries in this category were not eligible for the Supreme Award as the products should not be available for sale in any retail outlet, the aim being to encourage entries from hotels, restaurants, food institutes and other catering establishments.

The Gelato/Sorbet Category attracted a record 40 entries. Old favourites like Cookies and Cream competed with chocolate, nuts, meringue and a full range of NZ traditional and more exotic fruits (tamarillos, Amaregna cherries, etc). The category continues to grow with consumers enjoying the superior quality of fruit flavours possible in these formulations.

The Kids Choice category was judged by 8 children aged 7 and 8 years – from St Ignatious and Bayfield Schools. They took the task very seriously and while their initial reactions were all very favourable – their final judgment after evaluating the 11 ice creams entered in the category was discriminatory. Flavour was the chief determinant and while some ice creams found favour in appearance, if the flavour didn’t stack up – the overall appeal suffered.

Kids Choice judges, and helpers
Kids Choice Judging Team, from St Ignatious School, St Heliers, and Bayfield Primary, Herne Bay.

The category for plain Vanilla ice cream continues to present manufacturers with the challenge of producing the perfect texture and subtle dairy flavour in an ice cream without the luxury of using other than vanilla flavours to enhance the raw ingredients. Manufacturers can use this category not only to bench mark their products against competitors, but to gauge their process control. Again this year, for the fifth consecutive time, the Award for the Best Vanilla Ice cream went to Deep South 2007 Ltd for their French Vanilla Ice Cream.

After finding the task of judging packaging combined with export ice creams difficult in previous years, the section was split to judge Export Packaging separately, as well as creating a new category for Domestic Packaging. These categories were judged by Tom Robertson, a Senior Lecturer in Packaging at Massey University, assisted by Michael Parker, who both found the entries exciting and innovative.

The Gold Award for Export Packaging was awarded to Emerald Foods Ltd for the presentation of their Japanese Private Label Vanilla.

The Gold Award for Domestic Packaging was awarded to Kapiti Fine Foods for their 5 Litre Black Doris Plum packaging.

The Export Category, sponsored by Allberry House Ltd, included a range of vanilla ice creams destined for Japan and Asia. These products require the manufacturers to understand the market requirements for dairy based ice creams which differ markedly from local (NZ and Australia) ice creams.

Best in Category Winners, and Category Sponsors
Best in Category Winners, with Category Sponsors

JUDGING CATEGORIES & SPONSORS:
Category - Sponsored by
1 Standard Vanilla Ice Cream - Formula Foods Corporation Ltd
2 Standard Chocolate Ice Cream - Sensient Technologies Corporation
3 Standard Ice Cream with Additions - Kerry New Zealand ‘Simply’ Sugars
4 Premium Ice Cream - Danisco New Zealand Ltd
5 Open Creative - Chelsea Sugar
6 Kids Choice - International Flavours & Fragrances Ltd
7(a) Export Ice Cream - Allberry House Ltd
7(b) Export Packaging - Alto Packaging Ltd
8 Gelato and Sorbet - RD2 International Ltd
9 Low Fat with Additions - Hawkins Watts Ltd
10 Domestic Packaging - Huhtamaki Henderson Ltd

COMMENTS
The ice cream judges were impressed by the berryfruit flavours that were incorporated into many entries. A wonderful summer has provided a full fruit flavour that carried the freshness and authenticity of the fruit through to the ice cream.

Every year the competition continues to attract new entries as the industry is constantly challenged to produce new products and the number of entries from small manufacturers increases. A record number of entries (187 ice creams plus 29 entries for packaging) were submitted this year by 24 manufacturers – from the global manufacturer to smaller local owner operators. It was encouraging to see the quality of ice creams, gelatos and sorbets of especially the small operators who don’t always have access to the technology or R & D resources of larger companies.

The judging took place over two full days, hosted again by Massey University, Food Technology Department, with the help of their administration and laboratory staff. Students acted as stewards enabling the judges to focus on getting through the large number of entries.

The ice cream judges were Ms Kay McMath, Ms Joanna Boese and Ms Christine O’Sullivan all of Auckland, and Mr Garry Baker from Sydney.

The New Zealand Ice Cream Manufacturers’ Association celebrates it’s 80th year (the birthday cake is appropriately being made of ice cream!) and is testimony to the strength of the industry to survive increasing competition from imported products. Being a nation of dairy consumers – New Zealanders love their own unique style of ice cream. Indulgence without the guilt is the challenge for the supplier companies and manufacturers. The Ice Cream Awards will continue to promote creativity, excellence and innovation in the industry.

The FULL LIST OF 2007 AWARDS is here.
PHOTOS from the 2007 Awards judging and presentations are here.

Any further information is available from:
Mrs Jenny de Lisle
Mobile: 0274 946664
NZICMA Secretary Office: 04 385 1410
 

Back to top
NZ Ice Cream Awards 2006
2006 Awards judgesThe tenth New Zealand Ice Cream Awards were announced at the annual NZICMA Conference in NELSON on Thursday, 18th May 2006.

A record number of 185 entries (compared with 155 entries in 2005) were submitted by 19 manufacturers for judging by four expert judges (above), Ms Kay McMath, Ms Joanna Boese, Mr Garry Baker from Sydney, and Ms Christine O’Sullivan of Auckland. This year the Awards were held for the first time at Massey University, Albany campus in Auckland and students of the 4th year of the B.Technology (Food) ably acted as stewards. This enabled the judges to focus on the judging of the entries and to get through the large number of entries over a two day period.


The FULL LIST OF 2006 AWARDS is here.
PHOTOS from the Annual Conference and Awards are here.


2006 Awards judges
The team of judges: Kay McMath,Joanna Boese, Garry Baker and Christine O’Sullivan

International judging guidelines were followed with each ice cream being awarded the maximum possible marks of 100 and from this points were deducted for various imperfections in each of 4 areas:
Appearance defects
Body and texture
Flavour defects
Melting defects

Entries were in 9 categories which included an Export Category (to include/exclude packaging) and a category for Kids Choice. A new category was established for the first time this year to separate the gelato/gelati and sorbet products from ice cream products in the Open Creative Category ensuring that like entries were considered against products with similar composition.

Kids Choice judges, and helpers

The Kids Choice is judged by children – this year, 6 students from a new school (Oteha Valley School - see photo above, with Massey B. Tech. students) on the North Shore were selected to judge. The children were aged from 5 ½ years to 10 and despite being young in age they all managed to differentiate between the samples and determine clearly their likes (“yummy”) from their dislikes (“yukky”). The 3 boys and 3 girls took their role as ice cream judges very seriously – to the extent that the appearance of the media went entirely unnoticed.

The 4th year students acted as mentors for each child guiding them through the process and at the same time learning something of children’s persuasive powers when it comes to food (especially ice cream) choice.

The Supreme Award is given to the ice cream with the highest score across all categories. This year the Award went to the winner of the Premium Category with a score of 99 points.

The Supreme Award for 2006 went to Kapiti Fine Foods Ltd for their
Kapiti Lemon Meringue Pie

2006 Supreme Award winners
Winner of the Supreme Award: Kapiti Fine Foods - Leanne Court, David Lim & Marie Grandjonc

The Export Category was sponsored by Allberry House and consisted of two sections – one to include packaging and the other to exclude packaging. While there was little originality in the packaging that was presented – the winner of the export section to include packaging was a superb product with a flavour profile ideally suited to its target market of Japan. The winning product in the Export Inclusive of Packaging Category was Emerald Foods Ltd’s Vanilla Ice Cream. Green Tea Ice Cream made by New Zealand Natural was the winner of the Export Exclusive of Packaging Category. While the flavour was not everyone’s “cup of tea” – the flavour of this ice cream was so true to character it was hard to envisage you were eating the sample not drinking the beverage.

In the Open Creative Category there were joint winners, Deep South 2007 Ltd for their Coffee and Walnut Ice Cream and Prolux Pty Ltd for their entry Comprital Italian Hazelnut Praline Gelato. Entries in this Category were not eligible for the Supreme Award as the products do not have to be commercially available. This is to encourage entries from hotels, restaurants, food institutes and other catering establishments.

The Gelato/Gelati/Sorbet Category attracted an impressive 31 entries. Apple, berries, lemon and lime and even a champagne flavoured sorbet/gelato-gelati continued to excite the judges. The quality of the products was exciting with some wonderful natural, authentic fruit flavours being captured in these frozen treats. The Category is growing fast with consumers enjoying the superior quality of fruit flavours possible in these formulations.

The showcase of quality of New Zealand ice cream is no more evident than in the Standard Vanilla Ice Cream Category. The quality of raw ingredients – especially dairy, and the control of processes is very evident in these ice creams. Deep South 2007 Ltd’s French Vanilla continued its winning run of four consecutive Best in Category Awards in this class.

Best in Category Winners
Best in Category Winners

The record number of entries this year, and the increasing numbers of products in the Gelato / Sorbet and Low Fat categories may be a reflection of the changing market trends to more natural, healthier products with consumers being able to enjoy more of these guilt free products.

The New Zealand Ice Cream Awards is growing from strength to strength with new players entering the field, creativity abounding from our food technologists and new processes constantly challenging old methods. The first competition was held in 1997 and had 61 entries. The Ice Cream Awards will continue to promote excellence and innovation in the industry.

The FULL LIST OF 2006 AWARDS is here.
PHOTOS from the 2006 Annual Conference and Awards are here.

Back to top


NZ Ice Cream Awards 2005

Judging the best ice creams in New ZealandTHE NINETH NEW ZEALAND ICE CREAM AWARDS were presented at the anual NZICMA Conference in NAPIER on Friday, 17th JUNE 2005.

155 entries were submitted by 16 manufacturers for judging by four judges, Mr Garry Baker from Sydney, Ms Kay McMath, Ms Christine O’Sullivan and Ms Joanna Boese from Auckland.
(Photo: Judges at work - Garry Baker, Christine O'Sullivan, Joanna Boese, Kay McMath - from Food Technology in New Zealand)

International judging guidelines were followed with each ice cream being awarded the maximum possible marks of 100 and from this points were deducted for various imperfections in each of 4 areas:
Appearance defects
Body and texture
Flavour defects
Melting defects

The FULL LIST OF 2005 AWARDS is here.

Entries were in 9 categories which included an Export Category (to include/exclude packaging) and a category for Kids Choice. The Kids Choice is judged by children – this year selected from a Year 6 class at Panama Road School in South Auckland. The children, three boys and three girls from Room 13 couldn’t wait to seek parental permission to participate in the event. Parents, some in disbelief, had no hesitation in releasing the children for 2 hours – somewhat envious of the opportunity to participate in judging the 13 entries in the category. Flavours judged this year were Cookies and Cream, Mint Choc Kisses, Triple Chocolate, Golden Kiwifruit Pavlova, Hokey Pokey, Choco Mallow, Chocolate Crunch, Strawblimey Sours, Jelly Tip and Awesome Foursome ‘Family Fun’.

The kids were very black and white in their decisions and not afraid of using the scale from “really yuk” to “really yummy”. Even after evaluating the 13 entries in the category – they were very decisive in their overall choice. Their most preferred ice cream was Triple Chocolate made by Kapiti Fine Foods.

In the Open Creative Category the award went to Tip Top Ice Cream Company Ltd for their Manuka Honey and Macadamia ice cream. Entries in this category were not eligible for the Supreme Award as the products do not have to be commercially available. This category has been established to encourage entries from hotels, restaurants, food institutes and other catering establishments.

There was a successful introduction last year of a combined category for Gelato, Sorbet and Low Fat, however this year the Low Fat products were separated to enable judges to focus on the characteristics of each class. The Gelato/Gelati and Sorbet category continued to attract a record number of entries (32) and the Low Fat category a further 8 entries. The increasing trend of interest in these Categories versus the slight decline in the higher fat, premium category was interesting and may reflect changing consumer demands. As for last year – the quality of the Gelato/Sorbet continued to excite judges with the wonderful natural, authentic fresh fruit flavours being captured in these frozen treats.

The Supreme Award is given to the ice cream with the highest score across all categories. This year the award went to the winner of the Standard Ice Cream with Additions with a score of 99 points.

The Supreme Award for 2005 went to Tip Top Ice Cream Company Ltd for their
Saucy As Crazy for Caramel

The success of the workshop held last year at the Annual Conference of The New Zealand Ice Cream Manufacturers’ Association was just reason to repeat the exercise again this year. Conference attendees were able to sample some of the same products judged by the panel and to give their opinion on the tasting experience. This made the attendees more appreciative of the task faced by the judges but also to experience some of the issues discussed by judges in their reports to the ice cream manufacturers. Many attendees were keen to know the success of Deep South 2007 Ltd’s French Vanilla which took top honours in the Standard Vanilla Category without inclusions.

Trends evident in the use of flavours continue with the use of natural flavours and fruit purees, ripples and syrups. Manufacturers appreciate that consumers now know and expect true to natural flavours and are continuing to lift the bar to achieve both natural colours and flavours in their products. Gold kiwifruit and quince as ice cream flavours made their debut among the entries in the Premium Category this year.

Ice creams that provide a “dessert in a dish” also proved popular in both the Open Creative and Premium Categories. Apple Pie, Spicy Apple Crumble, Strawberry Cheesecake and Cookies and Cream were great examples of combinations of flavours that are traditionally served with ice cream accompaniments.

The New Zealand Ice Cream Awards continue to provide our industry with ever challenging yardsticks to be measured by. The innovation, creativity and manufacturing excellence are a credit to those who work in the industry and whose achievements stand among the best in the world.

The FULL LIST OF 2005 AWARDS is here.


Back to top


NZ Ice Cream Awards 2004
The eighth New Zealand Ice Cream Awards were announced at the NZICMA Annual Conference in Cairns on Friday, 18th June 2004.

The FULL LIST OF 2004 AWARDS is here.

143 entries were submitted by 12 manufacturers for judging by three expert judges, Mr Garry Baker from Sydney, Ms Kay McMath and Ms Christine O’Sullivan from Auckland.

International judging guidelines were followed with each ice cream being awarded the maximum possible marks of 100 and from this points were deducted for various imperfections in each of 4 areas:
Appearance defects
Body and texture
Flavour defects
Melting defects

Entries were in 8 categories which included an Export Category (to include/exclude packaging) and a category for Kids Choice. A new category was established for the first time this year to include the growing number of gelato/gelati and sorbet and low fat products.

The Kids Choice is judged by children – this year selected from a rural school, Alfriston, in South Auckland. The kids, three boys and three girls, aged 7 – 13, couldn’t believe their luck to score “their dream job”.

The Supreme Award is given to the ice cream with the highest score across all categories. This year the award went to the winner of the Premium Category with a score of 99 points.

The Supreme Award for 2004 went to Emerald Foods Ltd for their
Heavenly Treats Passionfruit Sorbet

Supreme Award winner -  Ken MilneThe kids were very analytical in their decisions and scoring, but overall their most preferred ice cream was Cookies and Cream 100% Natural Ice Cream made by Rush Munro’s of NZ Ltd of Hastings.

The Export Category was sponsored by NZ Trade & Enterprise who provided a cash prize. The winning product was Monte Bianco Almond Caramel made by Emerald Foods Ltd.

In the Open Creative Category the award went to Tip Top Ice Cream Company Ltd for their Caramelised Macadamia Nut ice cream. Entries in this category were not eligible for the Supreme Award as the products do not have to be commercially available. This is to encourage entries from hotels, restaurants, food institutes and other catering establishments.

The new category this year for Gelato/Gelati/Sorbet and Low Fat ice cream attracted an impressive 30 entries. The quality of the products was exciting with some wonderful natural, authentic fruit flavours being captured in these frozen treats. The category is growing fast with consumers enjoying the superior quality of fruit flavours possible in these formulations.

The judges complimented the manufacturers on improvements from last year. Texture defects of stickiness and gumminess were much reduced this year and those defects present were not so obvious to lose more than one point in most instances. Workshops were held at the Conference to train the manufacturers in some of the more common ice cream faults. All manufacturers agreed the experience was very enlightening and educational in demonstrating the judging process and scoring systems.

Comments from the judges indicated that it was much easier to score well in Standard ice creams without inclusions as the more complex the products, the more features there were to judge and fault. Vanilla ice cream without inclusions is New Zealand’s show piece of our superb dairy ingredients and manufacturing expertise and Deep South’s Vanilla continued its winning run of Gold Awards.

Ice cream provides an excellent carrier for some of the world’s best fruit flavours and the judges commented that while it was great to see the use of local fruit such as feijoa being cleverly used, the inclusion of berryfruits was disappointing. New Zealand has some of the best berryfruit in the world and yet this was not reflected in the flavours of some of our berryfruit ice creams. The use of tropical fruit flavours such as mango and passionfruit has also increased as consumers become more familiar with the characteristics of the fresh fruit.

Creative use of meringue pieces carefully added to ice cream mixes after churning worked well to add variety in both texture and flavour and bought the meaning of pavlova and ice cream a whole step closer.

The entries proved to be an excellent vehicle to demonstrate the skills and talent of our manufacturers, their product development teams and our supply of quality, fresh, flavoursome ingredients from our dairy, horticultural and flavour and confectionery industries. The Ice Cream Awards will continue to promote excellence and innovation in the industry.


Best in Categories:
Standard Vanilla Deep South 2007 Ltd Vanilla
Standard Chocolate Emerald Foods Ltd Chocolate
Standard with Additions Rush Munro’s of NZ Ltd Banana 100% Natural Ice Cream
Premium Ice Cream Emerald Foods Ltd Heavenly Treats Passionfruit Sorbet
Open Creative Ice Cream Tip Top Ice Cream Co Ltd Caramelised Macadamia Nut
Kids Choice Rush Munro’s of NZ Ltd Cookies & Cream 100% Natural Ice Cream
Export (Inclusive of Export Packaging) Emerald Foods Ltd Monte Bianco Lemon Paradise
Export (Exclusive of Points for Packaging) Emerald Foods Ltd Monte Bianco Almond Caramel
Gelato / Sorbet / Low Fat Gelato Toscana Feijoa Fusion
Export Award (overall) Emerald Foods Ltd Monte Bianco Almond Caramel
Supreme Award Emerald Foods Ltd Heavenly Treats Passionfruit Sorbet

Entries 143; Silver Awards 85, Gold Awards 24, Best in Categories 9, Export 1, Supreme 1.

The FULL LIST OF 2004 AWARDS is here.


Back to top


NZ Ice Cream Awards 2003
Judging the best ice cream in New ZealandThe seventh NEW ZEALAND ICE CREAM AWARDS
were held in association with the NZ Ice Cream Manufacturers' Ass'n. annual conference, in Invercargill, on Friday, 27th June 2003.
131 entries were submitted by 14 ice cream manufacturers for judging by three expert judges, Dr Alan Smyth of Melbourne, Mr Garry Baker from Sydney and Ms Kay McMath of Auckland.

International judging guidelines were followed with each ice cream starting off with 100 points from which points are deducted due to various imperfections such as - Appearance defects, Body and texture, Flavour defects, and Melting defects.

Entries are in 7 categories which includes Kids Choice judged by three local primary school children (two boys and a girl) selected by a competition held by Radio Foveaux.

The Supreme Award is given to the ice cream with the highest score across all categories, and this year was awarded to the winner of the Premium Category, with a maximum score of 100 points.

The Supreme Award winner is Chateau Creme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd -
'Killinchy Gold Chocolate Fudge Brownie'


Supreme Award winner -  Ken MilneThe kids were unanimous in their selection of 'Lollies and Jelly' made by Talley's Frozen Foods Ltd of Motueka, Nelson.

The Export Category was sponsored by Trade New Zealand who provided a prize including a package of market research services. This was awarded to Mövenpick Foods NZ Ltd for their 'Mövenpick Chocolate Truffle'.

A copy of Trade New Zealand's press release regarding growth in the Ice Cream Export Industry is here.

The winner of the Open Creative Category was Kapiti Cheeses Ltd with their 'Apple Crumble'. Entries in this category are not eligible for the Supreme Award as the products do not have to be marketed. This is aimed to encourage entries from hotels, restaurants and other catering establishments.

The full list of 2003 New Zealand Ice Cream Awards is here.

Dr Alan Smyth, who has over 20 years experience judging at ice cream competitions and has judged all previous New Zealand Ice Cream Awards, states that he has seen a significant improvement in the quality of entries. The quality of the vanilla ice cream had improved considerably as there were two Gold Awards in this category compared to none last year.

The judges also commented "that it should be fairly simple to use a well balanced mix formula with good quality, clean fresh dairy ingredients and process it correctly and produce a good, defect-free base ice cream, but this does not always happen. So much emphasis is placed on the additions when a reasonable degree of care with the base could be much more beneficial. They also reiterated that New Zealand has some of the best dairy products in the world and the industry needs to display them in their ice cream. The whole purpose of the Awards is to encourage continuing excellence in quality and innovation of flavours.

Best in Categories:
Standard Vanilla Deep South 2007 Ltd Vanilla
Standard Chocolate Chateau Créme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd Chocolate
Standard with Additions Deep South 2007 Ltd Hokey Pokey
Premium Ice Cream Chateau Créme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd Killinchy Gold Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Open Creative Ice Cream Kapiti Cheeses Ltd Apple Crumble
Kids Choice Talley's Frozen Foods Ltd Lollies and Jelly
Export Award Mövenpick Foods NZ Ltd Mövenpick Chocolate Truffle
Supreme Award Chateau Créme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd Killinchy Gold Chocolate Fudge Brownie

Entries 131; Silver Awards 52; Gold Awards 42.

The full list of 2003 awards is here.


Back to top

NZ Ice Cream Awards 2002
Supreme Award winner - Kapiti Cheeses' Andrew Trevis and Peter MurphyThe sixth NEW ZEALAND ICE CREAM AWARDS
were held in association with the NZ Ice Cream Manufacturers' Ass'n. annual conference, in Auckland, on Friday, 21st June 2002.

124 entries were submitted by 18 ice cream manufacturers for judging by two international expert judges, Dr Alan Smyth of Melbourne, Mr Lionel Poyen of Singapore and also dairy sensory evaluation expert, Miss Kay McMath of Auckland.

Entries were in 7 categories which included 'Kids Choice', judged by three local primary school children.

The Supreme Award is given to the most outstanding ice cream across all categories and this year was awarded to Kapiti Cheeses Ltd with a score of 99¾ points out of a maximum of 100.
Seen here accepting the Award from the Hon. Rodney Hide, MP, are Kapiti's Andrew Trevis and Peter Murphy.

The Supreme Award winner is Kapiti Cheeses Ltd with their 'Fig and Honey' Premium Ice Cream
The best ice cream in New Zealand


The kids were unanimous in their selection of Lollies and Jelly made by Talley's Frozen Foods Ltd.

The winner of the Open Creative Category was Kiwi Ice Cream Co Ltd with their Fruity Summer Crush. This category had the objective of trying to encourage entries from hotels, restaurants and catering establishments as well as manufacturers.

The full list of awards is here.

Dr Smyth, who has over 20 years experience judging at ice cream competitions and has judged all previous New Zealand Ice Cream Awards, said that he was disappointed this year at the quality of the vanilla ice cream which was evidenced by no entries receiving Gold Awards in this category.

The judges again reiterated the point that New Zealand has some of the best dairy products in the world and the industry needs to reflect this in their ice cream. The whole purpose of the Awards is to encourage continuing excellence in quality and innovation of flavours.

Further information is available from: Mr Pen Moore or Mrs Jenny de Lisle, NZ Ice Cream Manufacturers' Association, Phone +64 4 385 1410.

Best in Categories:
Standard Vanilla not awarded -
Standard Chocolate Rush Munro's of New Zealand Ltd Chocolate
Standard with Additions Chateau Creme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd Cookies 'n' Cream
Premium Ice Cream Kapiti Cheeses Ltd Fig and Honey
Open Creative Ice Cream Kiwi Ice Cream Co Ltd Fruity Summer Crush
Kids Choice Talley's Frozen Foods Ltd Lollies and Jelly
Export Award Tip Top Ice Cream Co Ltd Caramel
Supreme Award Kapiti Cheeses Ltd Fig and Honey

Entries 124; Silver Awards 26; Gold Awards 21.

The full list of 2002 awards is here.

 

Back to top
The best ice cream in New Zealand
NZ Ice Cream Awards 2001
The fifth
NEW ZEALAND ICE CREAM AWARDS were held in Greymouth on Friday, 6 July 2001.

117 entries were submitted by 15 ice cream manufacturers for judging by two international expert judges, Dr Alan Smyth of Melbourne and Mr Garry Baker from Sydney.

International judging guidelines were followed with each ice cream starting off with 100 points from which points are deducted due to various imperfections such as Appearance defects, Body and texture, Flavour defects, and Melting defects. (The full list of awards is here).

Entries were in 7 categories which includes Kids Choice judged by three ten year old local primary school children (two boys and a girl).

The Supreme Award was given to the most outstanding ice cream across all categories, this year awarded to the winner of the Export Category, with a maximum score of 100 points.

The Supreme Award winner is Chateau Creme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd for their 'Almond Caramel'

The kids were unanimous in their selection of 'Marshmallow Magic' made by Chateau Creme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd of Auckland.

The winner of the Open Creative Category was Wendy's Supa Sundaes with their 'White Chocolate Heaven'. This needs to be mentioned as they also scored the maximum of 100 points. Entries in this category are not eligible for the Supreme Award as the products do not have to be marketed. This is to try and encourage entries from hotels and restaurants.

In his summing up, Dr Smyth said that he has seen a significant improvement in the quality of entries. The quality of the vanilla ice cream had improved as there were four Gold Awards in this category compared to none last year.

Best in Categories:
Standard Vanilla Deep South Ice Cream Co Ltd French Vanilla
Standard Chocolate Westland Snowflake Chocolate
Standard with Additions New Zealand Ice Cream Co Ltd Berryfuit Bounty
Premium Ice Cream New Zealand Ice Cream Co Ltd Cookies and Cream
Open Creative Ice Cream Wendy's Supa Sundaes White Chocolate Heaven
Kids Choice Chateau Creme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd Marshmallow Magic
Export Award Chateau Creme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd Almond Caramel
Supreme Award Chateau Creme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd Almond Caramel

Entries 117; Silver Awards 37; Gold Awards 29

The full list of 2001 awards is here

 

Back to top

NZ Ice Cream Awards 2000
The fourth NEW ZEALAND ICE CREAM AWARDS
were held in Auckland on Friday, June 23rd, 2000.

110 entries were submitted by 13 ice cream manufacturers for judging by two international expert judges, Dr Alan Smyth of Melbourne and Mr Garry Baker from Sydney.

International judging guidelines were followed with each ice cream starting off with 100 points from which points are deducted due to various imperfections such as appearance defects, body and texture, flavour defects and melting defects.

Entries were in 7 categories, including "Kids Choice" judged by three ten year old Howick school children (two boys and a girl).

The Supreme Award is given to the most outstanding ice cream across all categories and this year it was impossible for the judges to separate two entries which each attained the maximum of 100 points.

The two joint Supreme Award winners were Kapiti Cheeses Ltd - 'Fig and Honey' and New Zealand Natural Pty Ltd -'Mango Sorbet'.

The kids were unanimous in their selection of 'Teletroubles' made by Deep South Ice Cream Co Ltd, of lnvercargill.

Dr Smyth, who has over 20 years experience judging at ice cream competitions and has judged all previous New Zealand Ice Cream Awards, states that he has seen a significant improvement in the quality of entries, but this year the quality of vanilla ice cream had slipped and there were no gold awards in this category.

Best in Categories:
Standard Vanilla Kiwi Ice Cream (1992) Co Ltd Standard Vanilla
Standard Chocolate Deep South Ice Cream Co Ltd Standard Chocolate
Standard with Additions New Zealand Ice Cream Co Ltd Chocolate Lamington
Premium Ice Cream Kapiti Cheeses Ltd Fig and Honey
Open Creative Ice Cream New Zealand Natural Pty Ltd Mango Sorbet
Kids Choice Deep South Ice Cream Co Ltd Teletroubles
Export Award Chateau Creme Delight Ice Cream Co Ltd Lemon Paradise
Supreme Award Kapiti Cheeses Ltd Fig and Honey
Supreme Award New Zealand Natural Pty Ltd Mango Sorbet
Entries 110; Silver Awards 38; Gold Awards 38
Back to top  

Home I About I Contact I Members I Join I Industry I Industry statistics I Awards I Links I Code of Practice

Copyright © 2002-2008 The New Zealand Ice Cream Manufacturers Association (Inc.) - NZ icecream industry, manufacturers and suppliers.
Contact: The Executive Secretary, NZ Ice Cream Manufacturers' Assn., PO Box 9364, Wellington, NEW ZEALAND.
Telephone +64 4 385 1410. Fax No. +64 4 384 3980. E-mail: info@nzicecream.org.nz